Home

How does the best interests of the child affect Family Court matters.

How does the best interests of the child affect Family Court matters.

Best Interests of the Child

What are in the Best interests of the child

 

When Australian courts, including the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA), are asked to make Parenting Orders by consent (i.e., Consent Orders that deal with arrangements for children), the paramount consideration is the best interests of the child.

 
The concept of the “best interests of the child” is the absolute polar star of Australian family law. However, how the court interprets this principle, handles parental dynamics, and applies it in practice has undergone significant evolution, culminating in sweeping legislative changes that took effect recently.
The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA) relies on a structured framework to evaluate these matters, moving firmly away from standard formulas and shifting toward highly individualised, safety-first assessments.
 
This principle is enshrined in Australian family law through Section 60CA of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). It means that all decisions about parenting arrangements, including parental responsibility, must prioritise the child’s well-being and development above all else, including the wishes or interests of the parents.
Even when parents agree on arrangements, reach their own agreement, and submit them as proposed Consent Orders, the Court (usually a Registrar in the first instance) must independently review these proposed orders and be satisfied that they are, in fact, in the child’s best interests before they can be made into legally binding orders.
To determine what is in a child’s best interests, the Family Law Act 1975, specifically Section 60CC, sets out a list of factors that the Court must consider. These are categorised into “primary considerations” and “additional considerations.”
 
Primary Considerations (Section 60CC(2)):
 
  1. The benefit to the child of having a meaningful relationship with both of their parents: The law recognises that it is generally in a child’s best interests to have both parents involved in their lives, including how they spend time with each parent, provided it is safe to do so.
  2. The need to protect the child from any physical or psychological harm or from being subjected to, or exposed to, abuse, neglect or family violence: This factor is given greater weight than the benefit of a meaningful relationship if there is a conflict between the two. Child safety is paramount, especially where there are risks of child abuse.
Additional Considerations (Section 60CC(3)):
 
These are numerous and allow the Court to take a holistic view of the child’s circumstances. They include:
  • The views expressed by the child and any factors (which may include the child’s age, maturity and/or level of understanding) that the court thinks are relevant to the weight it should give to the child’s views.

 

  • The nature of the relationship of the child with each of the child’s parents and with significant people in the child’s life (including any grandparent or other relative of the child).

 

  • The willingness and ability of each of the child’s parents to facilitate and encourage a close and continuing relationship between the child and the other parent.

 

  • The likely effect of any changes in the child’s circumstances, including the impact on the child’s life and the child’s living arrangements, and the likely effect on the child of separation from:

 

  • Either of his or her parents, or
    • Any other child, or other person (including any grandparent or other relative of the child), with whom he or she has been living.
  • The practical difficulty and expense of a child spending time with and communicating with a parent, and whether that difficulty or expense will substantially affect the child’s right to maintain personal relations and direct contact with both parents on a regular basis

 

  • The capacity of each of the child’s parents and any other person (including any grandparent or other relative of the child) to provide for the needs of the child, including emotional and intellectual needs.

 

  • The maturity, sex, lifestyle and background (including lifestyle, culture, traditions, cultural identity and cultural upbringing of the child and either of the child’s parents) of the child and of either of the child’s parents, and any other characteristics of the child that the court thinks are relevant.

 

  • If the child is an Aboriginal child or a Torres Strait Islander child:

 

  • The child’s right to enjoy his or her Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander culture (including the right to enjoy that culture with other people who share that culture); and

 

  • The likely impact of any proposed parenting order under this Part will have on that right.

 

  • The attitude to the child and to the responsibilities of parenthood is demonstrated by each of the child’s parents.

 

  • Any family violence involving the child or a member of the child’s family.

 

  • If family violence orders apply, or have applied, to the child or a member of the child’s family, any relevant inferences that can be drawn from the order, taking into account the circumstances in which the order was made, the evidence (if any) on which the order was based, any safety concerns, and any other relevant matter.

 

  • Whether it would be preferable to make the order that would be least likely to lead to the institution of further proceedings in relation to the child.
  • Any other fact or circumstance that the court thinks is relevant.
  •  
How it Applies to Consent Orders:
 
When parents submit an Application for Consent Orders for parenting arrangements, they are essentially stating that they believe these arrangements are in their child’s best interests. The court considers the application and the proposed orders against these legislative factors in light of the family’s particular circumstances.
  • The Court will consider the information provided by the parents in their application, including practical considerations, which should implicitly or explicitly address how the proposed arrangements meet the child’s needs and support the child’s wellbeing in light of these factors.
  • If the Court has concerns that the proposed orders are not in the child’s best interests (e.g., if they seem to expose a child to risk, or don’t adequately consider the child’s relationship with both parents where safe), it may:
  • Ask for more information.
  • Suggest changes to the proposed orders.
  • In some cases, refuse to make the orders as proposed and list the matter for a short hearing or direct parents to family dispute resolution.
Therefore, when parents are negotiating and drafting proposed Consent Orders for their children, they should focus on making arrangements that, where possible, reflect their own arrangements and frame their discussions and the resulting agreement around these “best interests” principles. This not only helps ensure the arrangements are genuinely good for their children but also increases the likelihood of the Court approving their agreement.
 

How the Court Considers the “Best Interests” (The Core Framework)

 

The court does not look at what is fair to the parents; it looks exclusively at what is best for the child. Under the overhauled Section 60CC of the Family Law Act 1975, the court evaluates a streamlined, non-hierarchical list of core factors:
 
  • Safety: The primary consideration is promoting the safety of the child and any person providing care (including protection from family violence, abuse, neglect, or harm).
  • The Child’s Views: The court considers any views expressed by the child, giving them direct weight based on their understanding and maturity, without requiring rigid secondary proofs.
  • Developmental, Psychological, Emotional, and Cultural Needs: A holistic evaluation of the child’s specific well-being requirements.
  • Parental Capacity: The capability of each proposed caregiver to actually provide for those developmental, emotional, and cultural needs.
  • The Benefit of Relationships: The benefit to the child of having a relationship with both parents and other significant people (like grandparents or siblings), provided it is safe to do so.
  • Catch-all Provision: Any other fact or circumstance relevant to the specific child.
  • Cultural Connection: For Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander children, a dedicated requirement to consider their right to enjoy and connect with their culture, language, and community.

 

How It Has Changed Over Time

 

The trajectory of family law has moved from rigid structural presumptions toward a highly discretionary, child-centric approach.
 

The Historic Era (Pre-2006)

The court operated under broader discretionary powers with less prescriptive legislative checklists. While the child’s welfare was paramount, orders often fell into standard patterns of one parent having “custody” and the other having “access” or “contact” every second weekend.
 

The 2006 Reforms (The “Shared Time” Confusion)

In 2006, the Howard Government introduced a dual-tier framework of “Primary” and “Additional” considerations. Crucially, it introduced a statutory legal presumption of “Equal Shared Parental Responsibility” (ESPR) for major long-term decisions.
  • The Flaw: If ESPR applied, the Act forced judges to mechanically consider whether the child spending equal time or substantial and significant time with both parents was reasonably practicable and in their best interests.
  • The Consequence: This created a widespread, incorrect public perception that parents had a “legal right to 50/50 shared time.” It frequently fueled high-conflict litigation, trapped families in unworkable parallel parenting arrangements, and sometimes compromised child safety in the pursuit of mathematical equality.

 

3. The Landscape and Opinion in 2026

 

We are now firmly entrenched in the post-reform era established by the Family Law Amendment Act, which commenced on 6 May 2024. The prevailing consensus among practitioners, independent experts, and the judiciary focuses on simplification, safety, and individualisation.

 

The Death of the Presumption

There is no longer any legal presumption of equal shared parental responsibility, nor is there any legislative mandate forcing the court to automatically consider equal or substantial time.

 

A Bespoke, Safety-First Approach

The “meaningful relationship” factor no longer shares a top-tier pedestal with safety. Safety is overwhelmingly the gatekeeper. The 2006 two-tier hierarchy of factors is gone. The court now treats the 60CC criteria as a flat, holistic matrix. This has paved the way for more flexible, tailored parenting orders, such as granting one parent sole responsibility for medical decisions while sharing educational decisions, depending entirely on the dynamics of the family.

 

4. Practical Implementation: Consent Orders & Family Law

Because the legislation has stripped away the default template of “50/50 split,” drafting and applying for Consent Orders or navigating litigation requires a meticulous, evidence-backed approach.

 

Drafted Consent Orders

When parents reach an agreement out of court and submit an Application for Consent Orders, the court does not just rubber-stamp it. Registrars and Judges review the proposed minutes against the new Section 60CC factors.

  • The “Why” Matters: Applications must clearly articulate why the agreed time split and decision-making structure align with the children’s specific practical, developmental, and emotional needs.

  • Consultation Clauses: While the presumption of ESPR is gone, the Act still encourages joint decision-making where safe. Practical orders now utilise distinct “consultation clauses,” explicitly defining how parents must notify and discuss major long-term issues (health, education, religion) with plain-English mechanisms for dispute resolution if they hit a deadlock.

Fact-Finding & Material Evidence

 

In contested tracks, affidavits cannot rely on vague assertions of “parental rights.” Evidence must tie directly back to parental capacity and child safety. The courts place heavy reliance on Family Reports and independent single-expert witness evaluations to assess the psychological and emotional landscape of the family units.

The elevated role of the ICL 

Where an Independent Children’s Lawyer (ICL) is appointed to represent the child’s best interests in complex or high-conflict matters, they now face a strict statutory obligation to meet directly with the child and give them a voice (if the child is over 5 and wishes to speak), ensuring the child’s view is directly injected into evidence rather than filtered solely through adult conflict.

Re-opening Final Orders (The Rice & Asplund Rule)

The common law rule from Rice & Asplund—stating that final parenting orders cannot be reopened unless there has been a significant change in circumstances—has now been codified. Under the current law, the court will not reconsider a final parenting order unless a significant change occurs and doing so is in the best interests of the child, thereby preventing vexatious or continuous litigation from disrupting the child’s stability.

FAQ on the best interests of the children

1. What does the "best interests of the child" principle mean under Australian family law?
Under the Family Law Act 1975, the “best interests of the child” is the single paramount consideration for courts when approving or deciding parenting orders. Rather than enforcing rigid default formulas or prioritising what parents want, this legal test puts your child’s physical safety, emotional stability, and developmental needs first. Courts evaluate safety from violence or neglect, the child’s views, the benefit of maintaining safe relationships, and each parent’s capacity to care for them. Read the full breakdown of how this principle works in Best Interests of the Child.
2. Does the "best interests" principle guarantee a 50/50 custody or equal time split?
No, Australian law contains no statutory guarantee or automatic right to equal time or 50/50 custody splits. Instead of starting with a rigid time formula, courts focus on creating practical, safe arrangements made to your child’s specific age, schooling, and emotional health. While building a strong relationship with both parents remains important, safety and daily stability override equal time considerations if a 50/50 arrangement creates stress or risk for the child.
3. How does the court assess my child's views when determining their best interests?
Courts evaluate a child’s expressed views by considering their age, psychological maturity, and overall level of understanding of the situation. Rather than requiring children to become involved in the court process, judges gather information through independent reports, such as a Child Impact Report or Family Report prepared by a Family court expert. The court will carefully weigh these perspectives to ensure the child’s voice shapes the final decision, rather than dragging them into parental conflict.
4. How does the law balance child safety against maintaining a relationship with both parents?
Child safety takes precedence whenever a conflict arises between protecting a child and maintaining contact with a parent. Courts prioritise keeping children and carers safe from physical or psychological harm, domestic abuse, and neglect above any desire for shared parenting time. This abuse can be both physical and emotional. If teh court believes that safety concerns exist, orders may restrict contact, require supervised changeovers, or order professional supervision to safeguard the child’s well-being.
To win court approval, your draft parenting orders must show how your proposed schedule supports your children’s daily routines, education requirements, and health needs. You can do this by submitting clear details about living arrangements, changeovers, and the day-to-day decision-making responsibilities in your application. A court registrar will review these terms in chambers to confirm the arrangement is safe, practical, and child-centred. They have a great deal of experience in this process.
Important Legal Disclaimer
This publication by Kate Austin Family Lawyers provides general information only. It does not constitute formal legal advice and does not account for your personal circumstances, current financial situation, or unique family dynamics. Family law is complex and changes frequently. Reading this content does not create a solicitor-client relationship. You should not act or rely on this information without professional guidance. Every situation is different, and all parties must seek independent legal advice tailored to their specific circumstances before attempting to alter any court orders. Contact a qualified family law practitioner to discuss your specific legal matter today.

About The Author

Rachel Stubbs

Rachel is the Principal of Kate Austin Family Lawyers and a Law Society Accredited Specialist in Family Law, with over 25 years of dedicated family law expertise.  Having spent most of her career engaged in family law litigation, Rachel now prioritises out of court resolutions for family law clients through consent orders.  Her extensive knowledge of family law and capacity to draft order for any situation, whether property or parenting, sees her clients in good hands and ensure a smooth, minimal stress pathway through the family law system. – Meet Rachel